Systems and specification
Condensation risk analysis: the roof is proved to dry before it is specified.
Insulating a roof changes where it gets cold, and so where moisture can form. Before HOLVEM specifies a build-up, it checks whether that roof will trap moisture: first with the simple method, and where that is inconclusive, with a dynamic simulation of ten years of real weather. The result is part of the specification.
01The question
Will this roof trap moisture?
Warm indoor air carries water vapour, and vapour moves outward through a roof all winter. Wherever it meets a surface colder than its dew point it condenses. In an insulated roof that surface is usually inside the build-up, on the cold side of the insulation, where nobody can see it. If more water forms each winter than dries out each summer, it accumulates year on year: wet insulation, a decaying deck, staining that appears long after the work.
Surface condensation and mould
Is any part of the inside surface cold enough, often enough, to grow mould? Judged by the temperature factor fRsi against a critical value.
Interstitial condensation
Does vapour condense on a layer inside the roof, and where? For a warm deck the plane to watch is the cold side of the deck, under the sheet.
Does it dry out?
Winter condensation is not the failure; failing to dry by the end of summer is. A roof that ends the year drier than it started is a roof that lasts.
02The simple method
First, the Glaser method: month by month, on averages.
BS EN ISO 13788 takes each month's average outdoor and indoor conditions, works out where the vapour pressure meets the saturation point inside the build-up, and adds up how much water condenses there, month by month. It is quick, standard, and deliberately cautious. The roof below is a real HOLVEM roof: a metal standing-seam flat roof in South East England, with 50 mm of closed-cell spray foam under the deck and 250 mm of mineral wool between the joists.
Condensate at the vapour control layer under the deck, accumulated, g/m²Rises from October, peaks in May, does not clear by September
No risk of mould growth on the inside face.
Still 79 g/m² in September. On this method the roof does not fully dry within the year, so it is flagged.
03Why a flag is not a verdict
The simple method is where the standard says to start, not where it says to stop.
A flag on the simple method means one of two things: the roof really will accumulate moisture, or the method's simplifications are hiding a roof that dries. BS EN ISO 13788 says itself that it simplifies dynamic processes. BS 5250:2021, the UK code of practice for moisture in buildings, points to dynamic hygrothermal simulation where the simple method is inconclusive. What matters is what happens next.
Ignore the flag.
Build it anyway because it has always been fine. The deck sits under the sheet where nobody looks, and a roof that does accumulate moisture fails slowly and expensively.
Over-specify.
Add a vapour barrier, a ventilated void, more depth or a different system to make the simple method pass. More cost, sometimes a worse roof, and a design driven by the limits of a method rather than by the building.
Prove the design.
Run the dynamic simulation the standard points to, with real weather, real materials and the membrane behaving as it does. If the roof dries, the specification stands on evidence. If it does not, the build-up changes before anything is sprayed.
BS EN ISO 13788The simple method. Monthly averages, vapour diffusion only, no moisture storage. Its own text notes that it simplifies dynamic processes.
BS 5250:2021The UK code of practice for the management of moisture in buildings. Where the simple method is inconclusive, it points to dynamic hygrothermal simulation to BS EN 15026.